Sole Trader or Company: What are the Tax Differences?

Cogger Gurry • May 13, 2025

You may be starting out in business and trying to decide whether to become a sole trader or to set up a company. Alternatively, you may already be an established sole trader and considering switching to become a company. Tax considerations are vital in deciding which of the two business structures is most suitable for you.


The first practical difference is in relation to your tax return. As a sole trader, you simply add your business income and expenses to a separate business and professional items schedule in your individual tax return that you lodge each year. For a company, there’s a separate annual tax return, and tax to pay on the company’s income. Companies are subject to annual reviews by the Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC), so financial records must clearly show transactions and the company’s financial position, and allow clear statements to be created and audited if necessary. A number of strict legal and other obligations need to be met.


Tax returns for a company must clearly list the income, deductions and the liable income tax of the company. Also, directors and any employees of a company must lodge their own individual tax returns.

There’s no tax-free threshold for companies – they simply pay tax on the amount they earn. This is at either the 25% or 30% company tax rate. To be eligible for the lower company tax rate of 25%, the company needs to meet strict requirements to be a base rate entity. One of the tests is that your company’s aggregated turnover for the relevant income year must be less than the aggregated threshold for that year – which since 1 July 2018 has been $50 million a year. For all companies that are not eligible for the lower company tax rate, the full company tax rate of 30% will apply. However, for sole traders, whose tax is assessed as part of the individual’s personal income, $18,200 is the tax-free threshold.


Both sole traders and companies can:

• Register for goods and services tax (GST) if your GST turnover is $75,000 or more, or you’d like to claim fuel tax credits; and regardless of your turnover, you must register for GST if you provide taxi, limousine or ride-sourcing services; and

• Employ people, and if the business’s gross wages exceed the threshold set by your state or territory, then you will have to pay payroll tax.


Both types of business also need to pay capital gains tax (CGT) if a capital gain has been made, but sole traders may be able to reduce this gain by what are known as the discount and indexation methods. The latter may also be used by some companies.


Please contact our office if you have any questions . T: 03) 5571 0111 E: reception@coggergurry.com.au or make an online enquiry www.coggergurry.com.au/coggergurry_contact_us




July 30, 2026
New Identity Verification Requirements – What Our Clients Need to Know From 1 July 2026, new Australian Anti-Money Laundering and Counter-Terrorism Financing (AML/CTF) legislation introduced additional obligations for accounting firms providing certain services. At Brentnalls Western Victoria, we are committed to making this process as simple and seamless as possible for our clients. Why are these changes happening? The new legislation is designed to help protect Australia's financial system from money laundering, terrorism financing and other financial crime. Many industries, including accounting, legal and real estate services, are now required to verify the identity of clients before providing certain regulated services. Will everyone need to verify their identity? No. These requirements only apply where we are providing a designated service under the AML/CTF legislation. We will notify you if your services falls under this category. Many of our clients will notice no change to the way we work together. If identity verification is required, we'll let you know and guide you through the process. How does the process work? Where identity verification is required, we'll send you a secure electronic verification request. The process is simple and usually takes just a few minutes using your smartphone or computer. You'll be guided through the steps, which may include: confirming your personal details providing identification documents (such as your driver's licence or passport) completing a quick facial verification to confirm your identity. Once your identity has been successfully verified, we'll continue with your engagement as normal. Is my information secure? Yes. We use BGLiD , a secure electronic identity verification platform designed specifically for Australian professional firms. Your personal information is encrypted and handled in accordance with Australian privacy laws. How can I help? If we ask you to complete an identity verification, we appreciate your prompt response. Completing the verification early helps us commence work without unnecessary delays. Want to know more? For more information about Australia's AML/CTF reforms and why businesses may ask for identification, visit the Australian Transaction Reports and Analysis Centre (AUSTRAC): AUSTRAC – Why you might be asked for ID Questions? If you have any questions about these new requirements or the identity verification process, please contact our team. We're happy to explain what the changes mean for your individual circumstances.
July 20, 2026
We are delighted to announce the promotion of Erin White to Principal and Business Manager at Brentnalls Western Victoria. Since joining the firm in 2024, Erin has played a key role in leading our people, strengthening our operations and helping shape the future direction of the firm. Erin's progress in the firm reflects her leadership across our business and her commitment to delivering exceptional outcomes for both our clients and our team. In addition to overseeing business operations, people and culture, strategic projects and marketing, Erin also works alongside clients to help them build stronger businesses through strategic planning and practical implementation. Having grown up, attended school and raised her two sons, Deacon and Xavier, in Western Victoria, Erin is passionate about supporting the businesses that help our regional communities thrive. Outside of work, she enjoys travelling, camping and spending time with her partner, Nathan, family and friends. Please join us in congratulating Erin on this exciting step. We look forward to the continued leadership and expertise she will bring to Brentnalls Western Victoria and to the positive impact she'll continue to have on our clients, our people and our community.
By Cogger Gurry July 20, 2026
Succession Starts Long Before Retirement With Stacey Shelden, Director, Brentnalls Western Victoria One of the biggest misconceptions I see is that succession planning begins when someone is ready to retire. In reality, that's often when families find themselves under pressure. The most successful succession plans I've been involved with didn't begin because someone wanted to step away from the business. They began years earlier, with simple conversations about the future. As we begin a new financial year, many business owners are taking stock of the year that's been and planning for the one ahead. They'll review financial performance, discuss tax outcomes, consider investments and set business goals. They're all important conversations. But I'd encourage you to ask one more question: Where do we want this business to be in ten years' time and are we preparing for that future today? Succession isn't simply about transferring ownership. It's about ensuring your business, your family and the next generation are ready for what's ahead. It means sharing knowledge, mentoring future leaders and gradually introducing the next generation to the decisions that shape the business. It means creating opportunities for them to understand not only how the business operates, but why decisions are made. Just as importantly, it means having open conversations as a family. Do everyone’s expectations align? Does the next generation actually want to take over the business? What does a successful transition look like for each family member? These conversations can feel difficult, which is why they're often delayed. Yet, in my experience, it's the families who start talking early who navigate succession with the greatest confidence. They have time to explore options, work through differing views and make decisions without the pressure of looming retirement or unexpected life events. The start of a new financial year is a natural time to think beyond the next twelve months. While you're planning for business growth and reviewing financial performance, take the opportunity to also consider your long-term vision. Because succession isn't a project to complete when retirement arrives. It's a process of preparing your business, and your family, for the future. The earlier you begin, the more choices you'll have, and the stronger your business will be for the generations that follow.
More Posts